My Photo

Crossword Analysis

  • XWord Info
    The sister site to this blog lets you dive into clues, answers and authors, see every puzzle since 1993, and find answer words based on known letters.
  • Why are the dates wrong?
    In syndication, the Sunday NYT puzzle runs a week behind, and the dailies are six weeks behind. The easiest way to find the puzzle you want is to go to the Calendar and count back the appropriate number of weeks.

Animations

Special Reports

Puzzle Links

« An Inconvenient Truthiness | Main | TypePad woes »

June 17, 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83455946669e200e5535964df8833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Major muddle:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

PhillySolver

Thanks for the blogomtic link.

I gave a lecture once on the Christmas Story with historical markers to separate the myths from the written word. One of the common errors is believing their were three wise men(MAGI) Matthew doesn't say and early Christian art shows as many as twelve. The number three was introduced as part of Renaissance art to create the required 'perfect pyramid' in portrait painting. What they were actually doing and why is another great story, but it is not what you think.

I agree the puzzle is artfully done and seems TIMEly and not a bit DATEd.

ArtLvr

Hi Jim -- So glad to find you in the wee hours! This often fits my schedule, (or sometines lack of one), and I have yet to explore all your links. You and Philly are veritable fonts (founts?) of wisdom.

Is the quotation below just a tease/joke, Philly, or is there more? Loved the bit about the Ideal Three stemming from Renaissance esthetic: if I knew that, I'd forgotten! Thanks, both of you....

∑;)

"What they were actually doing and why is another great story, but it is not what you think." C'mon, give!

JimH

Yeah, PS, you can't just leave us guessing!

Mark Waldstein

Ahhh, Jim, you don't have a 17-year-old girl in your household. Otherwise "angst" would have popped into your head immediately. (Along with a few other less charitable epithets.)

PhillySolver

The Magi were astrologist. The Christmas Story speaks of a star and yet no one other than the wise men see it. Read the New Testament (only in Matthew) and it should seem strange that the Magi, who do, travel West to see a star that appears in the East. What they are doing is noting the appearance of an alignment of the planets in about 4 AD. The Ancient Zodiac divided the stars into the twelve kingdoms so that the heavenly events predicted what was happening in them. When Jupiter (the planet that spoke of Kings) aligned with the appearance of the sign for a great teacher and a prophet, they decided to travel to that kingdom (Judah) and met with the King (Herod), who had no idea. Knowing the approximate date of the birth (months earlier) they offered Gold (a gift for a King), Frankincense (a gift for a Prophet) and Myrrh (a gift for a religious leader). The later is often confused as predicting death, but while Myrrh was used to anoint the dead, its use was overseen by a Rabbi. There is a great deal more to the story in terms of which planets, the numerology and the historical evidence and what retrograde movement has to do with the story. There is some evidence that the sky in question had another event and it appears to have been in April. There really is a whole lot more, but I hope that helps.

ArtLvr

whew! I'm glad I asked, Philly, but now I'm really confused... Your audiences in those kinds of lectures must have been thrilled, though! Mystery within enigma within conundrum, whatever that quotation...
Thanks very much!

∑;)

joon

i thought the number three had more to do with matching up the magi with their gifts than with any kind of renaissance painting aesthetic. i'm pretty sure the names caspar, balthasar and melchior have been around since before 1000 AD, so they must have decided by then how many there were.

KarmaSartre

Good puzzle. I did want NOSEDove instead of DIVED, just because. And Major Muddle sounds like a name in an early, abandoned, Joseph Heller draft.

Speaking of astrology, where is the constuctor/sign database? I once asked a young man for a recommendation for a recording Beethoven's Fifth, and he gave me a run-down of the conductors/signs: "If you like bombastic, go with the Von Karajan, he's an Aries."

Donald

I am constantly amazed at the pyrotechnical wizardry of your blog -- I believe that it has to be the center of the crossworld with its information, links, puzzle history, and your commentary -- I am stunned by your programming of facts and figures, and now you've added "overview" which enables your readers to make only one visit for crosswords... here!

Of course, we'll miss our ratings, but you're the best!

JimH

@ Donald, not sure what you mean by missing your ratings. If you’re referring to your stats, I expect your hit count will go up. Your site will be credited with a page hit to your syndication feed every time my blogosphere page needs to refresh. Readers still have to click through to the original blog to read comments and that's where a lot of the interesting action is.

Donald

Jim

My comment is pure compliment to your entire site, nothing less -- beautiful work in all respects!

PhillySolver

joon

Drop me an email (I can't find a link on your ID) and I'll tell you a bit more about the Renaissance painting aspect of the Magi story.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Quick Search

  • Enter a clue, answer, or topic:

December 2009

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    

Analytics